What Makes a Great Artisan Olive Oil – And How to Choose the Right One
Olive oil isn’t just a kitchen staple — it’s a liquid expression of place, process, and time. From sun-drenched groves to hand-harvested olives and meticulous cold-pressing, great olive oil carries the story of its origin in every drop. But with so many labels, terms, and qualities on the market, it’s easy to feel overwhelmed. What does “extra virgin” really mean? Is “first press” better? And how do you know if the bottle you’re buying is worth it?
This guide cuts through the noise. Whether you’re drizzling it over burrata or searing vegetables, we’ll help you understand how olive oil is made, what defines its quality, and how to choose the right one for your table.
A Brief History of Olive Oil
Few ingredients have shaped human civilization quite like olive oil. Cultivated for over 6,000 years, the olive tree traces its roots to the Eastern Mediterranean — regions that are now parts of modern-day Syria, Palestine, and Israel. From there, olive cultivation spread across the Mediterranean basin, becoming central to the cultures of Ancient Greece, Rome, and beyond.
In antiquity, olive oil wasn’t just food. It was used in medicine, religious rituals, cosmetics, and even as fuel for lamps. Hippocrates called it “the great healer,” while the Greek poet Homer, in The Iliad, famously referred to it as “liquid gold.” It was so valuable that it became a cornerstone of trade, wealth, and diplomacy.
Over millennia, techniques evolved — from ancient stone presses to today’s precision cold extraction. But one thing hasn’t changed: olive oil remains a symbol of health, heritage, and exceptional taste — and a staple without which good cooking is simply unimaginable.
How Olive Oil Is Made
Olive oil isn’t just an ingredient — it’s one of Europe’s most iconic food products. Around 3 million tonnes are produced globally each year, and about two-thirds of that comes from the EU. Spain leads the way (66% of EU production), followed by Italy (15%), Greece (13%), and Portugal (5%).
But quantity is only half the story. Quality depends on how the olives are grown, harvested, and transformed — step by step — into oil. Here’s how it happens.
From Tree to Mill — The Harvest
It all starts in the grove. The quality of olive oil is shaped long before it reaches the mill — and harvest timing is everything. Most high-quality oils are made from early-harvest olives, picked between October and November. At this stage, the olives are firmer, greener, and higher in polyphenols — the compounds responsible for flavor, aroma, and health benefits.
Small-scale producers often harvest by hand or with gentle mechanical aids to avoid bruising the fruit. Once picked, the olives are transported quickly — ideally within hours — to a nearby mill. Speed is crucial. The longer olives sit after harvest, the more they risk fermentation and oxidation, which can lead to off-flavors and increased acidity.
Cold Extraction — The Modern Standard
Once the olives reach the mill, they’re processed using purely mechanical methods — no heat, no solvents, no chemicals. This is what qualifies an oil as “extra virgin.”
The first step is crushing, where the whole olive (including the pit) is ground into a thick paste. This paste is then malaxed — gently stirred — for 20 to 45 minutes. Malaxation helps the microscopic oil droplets combine, but it must be done carefully and under controlled temperatures. Too much heat can degrade the oil’s quality and strip away delicate aromas.
After malaxation, the paste is sent through a centrifuge, which separates the oil from the water and solid material. The result is a cloudy, vibrant green liquid — pure olive oil, full of flavor and polyphenols. And all of it produced without refining or additives.
This cold extraction process (legally defined as remaining below 27°C) is now the global standard for high-quality extra virgin olive oils.
Filtration and Bottling
Once the oil has been separated, producers face a choice: to filter or not to filter. Some oils are filtered to remove small particles of olive flesh and moisture, which can help extend shelf life and preserve clarity. Others are left unfiltered for a slightly cloudier appearance and a more rustic flavor profile. Both approaches are valid — it comes down to style, stability, and the producer’s preference.
After settling or filtration, the oil is bottled — ideally in dark glass or metal tins to protect it from light. The best producers bottle shortly after extraction to preserve freshness and seal in volatile aromas. Some even nitrogen-flush the bottles to reduce oxidation before sealing.
From grove to glass, the entire process often takes as little as one week — rarely more than three — and reflects a balance of tradition, precision, and care. These are the hallmarks of true extra virgin olive oil.
Types of Olive Oil Explained
Not all olive oils are created equal. In fact, the differences between them are substantial — from how they’re extracted to whether they’re even fit for consumption. Understanding these categories is the first step to buying with confidence.
Extra Virgin Olive Oil (EVOO)
The highest grade of olive oil — extracted purely by mechanical means, without the use of chemicals or heat, from fresh, defect-free olives. It’s fruity, must have free acidity below 0.8%, and meet strict standards in sensory evaluation. Extra virgin olive oil is valued for its vibrant aroma, layered flavor profile, and superior nutritional content. It’s the gold standard for drizzling over dishes, whisking into dressings, dipping with bread, finishing plates — and yes, even cooking, thanks to its stability at moderate heat.
Virgin Olive Oil
Like EVOO, virgin olive oil is produced mechanically without chemical treatment. While still somewhat fruity, it may exhibit minor sensory defects and has a slightly higher free acidity — up to 2.0%. While still suitable for food use, it’s often milder in flavor and less robust in aroma.
Olive Oil (composed of refined olive oil and virgin olive oils)
This oil combines refined olive oil (chemically treated to remove defects and acidity) with a portion of virgin or extra virgin oil to add flavor. While more stable for high-heat cooking, it lacks the complexity and health benefits of true extra virgin. Its acidity shall not exceed 1%.
Olive Pomace Oil (composed of refined olive-pomace oil and virgin olive oils)
Extracted from the residual olive pulp after initial pressing using solvents and heat, then blended with virgin oil for taste. It’s considered food-grade but of lower quality — suitable for commercial frying or industrial food production, not fine cooking. It must have an acidity level below 1%.
Other Olive Oils Not Meant for Direct Consumption
Not all olive oils are intended for your kitchen. Some are low-grade byproducts — including lampante oil and crude pomace oil — that are classified as unfit for direct human consumption. These oils have off-flavors or are extracted using heat and solvents, and must undergo refining before entering the food chain.
Even once refined, these oils lack the flavor, aroma, and health benefits of true extra virgin olive oil. They're typically used for industrial food processing or commercial frying — not for quality cooking at home.
What Makes High-Quality Olive Oil?
Not all olive oils deserve a spot in your pantry — and price alone isn’t a guarantee of quality. Truly exceptional olive oil is defined by how it’s made, where it comes from, and how well it’s preserved. Here’s what to look for when choosing a bottle worth savoring.
Harvesting and Production Methods
The foundation of quality begins at the grove. High-grade oils are made from fresh, carefully harvested olives, ideally picked early in the season (October–November) when polyphenol content is highest. These olives are transported quickly to the nearby mill to avoid fermentation, then processed using only mechanical means — without heat or solvents. This cold extraction method, typically kept below 27°C, helps preserve the oil’s flavor, aroma, and antioxidant profile. The cleaner and faster the process, the better the oil.
Scale of Production
Real quality often comes from the hands of small-scale growers and producers — not industrial brands. Artisan olive oils are typically made in limited batches, with a strong focus on freshness, traceability, and traditional methods. These producers harvest by hand, press locally within hours, and avoid shortcuts in favor of craftsmanship. The result is oil that’s fuller in flavor and nutritional value — far more aligned with what extra virgin is meant to be, and worlds apart from the ones lining supermarket shelves.
Origin and Terroir — Does It Matter?
Absolutely. Just as with wine, the taste of olive oil is deeply influenced by its terroir — the combination of soil, climate, altitude, and olive variety. A Sicilian Nocellara will taste vastly different from a Koroneiki grown in Crete. Protected Designation of Origin (PDO) and Protected Geographical Indication (PGI) labels add a layer of traceability, ensuring the oil comes from a certified region with defined practices. But even beyond labels, transparency about sourcing is a strong signal of quality.
Acidity, Freshness, and Storage
Free acidity is a key chemical indicator — high-quality extra virgin olive oil must remain below 0.8%. While acidity isn’t something you can taste directly, it reflects how carefully the olives were handled during harvesting and processing. The lower the acidity, the better the quality.
Olive oil doesn’t age like wine — it peaks shortly after pressing and begins to degrade with time, light, and air. That’s why freshness is equally crucial. Oxidation, caused by exposure to light, heat, and oxygen, is the main enemy. Look for harvest dates close to the time of purchase, and always store your oil in a cool, dark place, tightly sealed. Packaging matters, too: dark glass bottles or metal tins offer the best protection from light. Once opened, aim to use the bottle within 3–6 months for the best sensory and nutritional experience.
Organic — Is It Always Better?
Organic certification means the olives were grown without synthetic pesticides or fertilizers, and the groves meet specific ecological standards. While this can be a sign of thoughtful farming, it doesn’t guarantee superior flavor or freshness. A non-organic extra virgin olive oil from a small producer like Spanish SOLO Aceite, for example, using impeccable practices may far exceed a mass-market organic-certified oil in both taste and quality. In the end, transparency, harvest timing, and proper handling matter more than any single label.
Grower-Owned vs. Outsourced Brands
Not all bottles are what they seem. Many “gourmet” or design-driven olive oil brands don’t produce anything themselves — they buy bulk oil, outsource everything, and focus on marketing the brand. In contrast, grower-owned producers control the full process from tree to tin. They know their groves, their harvests, their pressing — and it shows in the integrity and flavor of the final product. That’s the kind of EVOO worth buying — from a producer worth supporting.
How to Read an Olive Oil Label
A well-designed label doesn’t just look good — it should tell you exactly what’s in the bottle, where it comes from, and why it’s worth your trust. We’ve gathered the most important things to look for — think of this as your cheat sheet for buying better olive oil, whether you’re shopping online or scanning shelves at your local market.
Type
Start by checking the type of olive oil. Extra virgin olive oil is the highest quality — cold-extracted, unrefined, and full of natural aroma, flavor, and antioxidants. It’s the top choice not only for finishing dishes, but also for cooking. If it doesn’t say “extra virgin,” skip it. Terms like “pure,” “light,” or “100% olive oil” usually signal refined, lower-grade blends.
Bottle Material
Choose dark glass or metal tins — never clear bottles. Olive oil is sensitive to light, and transparent packaging accelerates oxidation. If a brand chooses marketing over preservation, that’s a red flag.
Variety
High-quality producers proudly state the olive variety (or varieties, if it’s a blend) used. According to the International Olive Council, there are over 1,000 olive varieties grown worldwide, though only around 150 are regularly used for eating or oil production. Varieties like Nocellara, Picual, and Koroneiki are among the most popular ones — but don’t be shy about trying lesser-known types. These can reveal unexpected nuances and intriguing flavor profiles. There is no such thing as “better” or “bad” olive varieties — what matters is freshness, handling, and origin. Bottles without varietal information usually signal mass production — likely blends of various origins and varieties.
Harvest Date
The harvest date tells you two things — how fresh the oil is, and indirectly, whether it actually comes from a single harvest. Olive oil is at its best within months of being harvested. Look for a bottle that clearly states the specific harvest month and year, typically October–November in the Northern Hemisphere. You’ll notice that many extra virgin olive oils don’t list this — often a sign of large-scale blends made from oils harvested at different times, sometimes even across multiple seasons.
Origin Transparency
Good oils proudly state where their olives were grown — not just where the oil was bottled. “Product of Italy” means little without knowing the specific region or grove. Look for single-origin or region-specific information to ensure you’re buying an oil that truly reflects its terroir and not a generic blend from mixed sources.
Certifications (PDO, PGI, Organic)
These can add credibility — especially PDO and PGI, which are linked to specific, verified growing regions. Organic is a bonus, but not a guarantee of flavor. Remember, great oils also come from small-scale producers without any labels at all.
How to Taste and Evaluate Olive Oil
You don’t need to be a professional to evaluate olive oil — but once you know what to look for, you’ll never see (or taste) it the same way again. Tasting helps you identify freshness, spot flaws, and appreciate the oil’s true character. It’s not about being fussy — it’s about learning to trust your senses and choose oils that are worth your money.
Aroma, Bitterness, and Pepperiness
These are the three core characteristics assessed in every olive oil tasting — and all three should be present in a high-quality extra virgin olive oil.
Aroma: Fresh olive oil should smell alive — think green grass, herbs, tomato leaf, or even citrus. If it smells flat, musty, or greasy, it’s likely past its prime or poorly made.
Bitterness: This isn’t a flaw — it’s a feature. Bitterness reflects the presence of antioxidants (polyphenols), and it often shows up on the sides of the tongue. Oils made from early-harvest olives tend to be more bitter, which is a good sign.
Pepperiness: That peppery, ticklish sensation at the back of your throat is a classic marker of a fresh, high-polyphenol oil. If it makes you cough — even better. In the tasting world, this is called the “one-cough” or “two-cough” test.
Common Flavor Notes in Premium Oils
Just like wine, high-quality olive oils carry a distinct flavor profile shaped by variety, harvest timing, and terroir. The best oils don’t taste like oil — they taste like something.
You might notice green, vegetal notes like fresh-cut grass, green almond, or artichoke. Some oils lean more toward herbaceous or peppery tones, with hints of arugula, rosemary, or wild herbs. Others reveal fruitier notes — green banana, apple, even citrus peel — especially in early-harvest oils. To truly appreciate these nuances, it’s best to start with single-variety oils, where the flavor of one cultivar shines through clearly.
No two oils taste exactly alike, and that’s the beauty. The more oils you try, the more you’ll learn to recognize balance, intensity, and complexity. With time, your palate will start picking up what the label can’t tell you.
How to Taste Olive Oil at Home
Tasting olive oil is simple — and once you know how, you’ll never pick up a bottle the same way again. Here's how to do it properly:
1. Pour a small amount into a glass or cup
About a tablespoon is enough. Professional tasters use blue glasses to mask the color, but at home, any small glass will do.
2. Warm the oil with your hand
Cup the glass with one hand and cover the top with the other. Gently swirl it for 30 seconds to release the aromas.
3. Smell deeply
Lift the cover and inhale. You should smell something green, fruity, herbal — not greasy or flat. If it smells musty or stale, the oil may be defective or past its prime.
4. Sip and slurp
Take a small sip and “slurp” it quickly across your tongue, drawing in a bit of air. This spreads the oil and helps release volatile flavor compounds.
5. Swallow and wait
Notice the bitterness (on the tongue) and the pepperiness (in the throat). A slight burn or even a cough is normal — and a good sign of freshness and polyphenol content.
You can also try the oil with a neutral piece of bread or raw vegetables — but tasting it straight, even just once, will tell you more than any label ever could.
Best Uses for Different Olive Oils and Storage Tips
Great olive oil isn’t just for drizzling on salads or dipping bread — it’s a foundational ingredient for everyday cooking. But not all oils are suited for every purpose. Understanding how and when to use different types helps you get the most flavor and value out of every bottle.
Cooking vs. Finishing — When to Use Which
Yes, you absolutely can cook with extra virgin olive oil — and you should. Despite common myths, high-quality EVOO is stable at moderate temperatures and is a cornerstone of traditional Mediterranean cooking. Its richness in monounsaturated fats and antioxidants makes it not only delicious, but also a healthy choice.
Flavor-wise, it enhances everything from vegetables and legumes to seafood and meat. It’s excellent for sautéing, roasting, baking — even shallow frying. That said, if you're deep-frying at high temperatures, a neutral oil with a higher smoke point may be more appropriate.
The key nuance? Heat will mute EVOO’s most delicate aromas and top notes — those green, grassy, or floral flavors that make it special. That’s why many home cooks and chefs keep two bottles on hand:
In the end, the distinction between cooking and finishing depends on personal taste and the dishes you prepare. What matters is understanding how your oil behaves — and making each drop count.
Storage Tips to Keep Olive Oil Fresh
Olive oil is a natural product — and like any fresh ingredient, it degrades over time. Heat, light, and oxygen are its biggest enemies. The moment the bottle is opened, the countdown begins. Here’s how to store your oil to keep it fresh and flavorful:
And remember: olive oil doesn’t get better with age. The fresher, the better.
Ready to Taste the Difference? Explore Artisan Olive Oils on Gourmie Goods
Discover our collection of single-variety extra virgin olive oils sourced from small-scale producers across Europe — each one chosen for its outstanding flavor, craftsmanship, and integrity.
Grown, harvested and crafted by families dedicated to mastery of olive oil production, these oils are full of character, nutrients, and flavour. Every bottle reflects its unique terroir — from Spanish valleys to Greek groves — bringing exceptional taste to your kitchen and elevating every dish you prepare.
